Seventh East-West Symposium of New Testament Scholars. Eastern European Liaison Committee of the Studiorum Novi Testamenti Societas, 26.09.2016–01.10.2016.
Reviewed by Volker Rabens
Published on H-Soz-u-Kult (January, 2017)
History and Theology in the Gospel Narratives: The Seventh East-West Symposium of New Testament Scholars
The Seventh East-West Symposium of New Testament Scholars was held in Moscow, from September 26 to October 1, 2016. Almost 100 participants (including several day visitors from Moscow) had come together from various parts of the world to discuss “History and Theology in the Gospel Narratives.” The symposium was organized by the Eastern European Liaison Committee of the Studiorum Novi Testamenti Societas (SNTS) under the leadership of Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr (Jena, Germany) at the invitation of Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk and in collaboration with Prof. Mikhail Seleznev (Moscow).
The symposium was opened by a public lecture of METROPOLITAN HILARION (Mowcow, Russia) on “The ‘Demythologization’ of New Testament Studies.” In his paper, the Metropolitan identified two traditions of New Testament scholarship: one strand goes back to the disciples of Jesus, the other to the liberal theologians of the nineteenth century. According to Hilarion, New Testament scholarship is at the crossroads and has to choose between having its foundation in Jesus himself or in modern myths and dogmas inspired by liberal ideologies. He appealed to the participants of the symposium to take the text of the Gospels in its totality as the foundation for research, studying it in both its historical context and in theological perspective in the light of the Church’s tradition. Hilarion’s paper ignited a lively discussion, to which the steering committee of the symposium devoted extra space on the final day of the conference, chaired by the current president of SNTS Carl Holladay (Atlanta, GA, USA). Senior scholars William Loader (Perth, Australia), Joel Marcus (Durham, NC, USA) and Francis Watson (Durham, UK) were invited to present responses to Hilarion’s paper. Apart from various points of agreement, they were not fully convinced that New Testament scholarship is at the crossroads of two paths leading into opposite directions. Among other things, they pointed towards the much more nuanced positions of recent critical scholarship. In the course of a friendly discussion, Hilarion defended his views, particularly his skepticism with regard to Historical Jesus studies. For example, when studying different versions of the Beatitudes, he maintained that there is no need to identify different layers of (later) traditions because Jesus may have preached different versions of the Beatitudes throughout the years of his ministry.
The other invited papers of the symposium dealt both with the individual Gospels as well as with overarching themes. JOEL MARCUS spoke about Matthew as historian and theologian. VLADAN TATALOVIC (Belgrade, Serbia) elucidated the role of the passion narrative in Matthew in Slavonic and in modern Serbian exegesis. FRANCIS WATSON’s paper on Mark looked at faith, history, and memory in the Second Gospel. COSMIN PRICOP (Bucharest, Romania) then investigated the transfiguration story in Mark, devoting special attention to Eastern and Western traditions (“Between Criticism and Patristics”). While none of the invited papers had an exclusive focus on the Gospel of Luke, the Third Gospel was one of the thematic options of the afternoon seminars to choose from – in variation with seminar papers on the other Gospels, discussions of the main papers and short presentations of current research projects. Two main papers were devoted to John’s Gospel: MARGARETA GRUBER (Vallendar, Germany) spoke about the presentation of Jesus in the light of paschal imagination as a ‘performer’ of his death and resurrection in John 2:13–23, and ANATOLY A. ALEXEEV (St. Petersburg, Russia) discussed John’s way from Christology to theology. On a more general note, ARMAND PUIG I TÀRRECH (Barcelona, Spain) introduced the audience to a polyhedric approach to the figure of Jesus in the canonical Gospels. MIKHAIL SELEZNEV discussed the question whether one can comprehend the “Theology of the Septuagint” as praeparatio evangelica. TOBIAS NICKLAS (Regensburg, Germany) directed the attention to extra-canonical Gospels, investigating their historical impact and theological contribution. Finally, focusing on the Wirkungsgeschichte of the Gospels, STEFANOS ALEXOPOULOS (Washington, USA) presented an overview of the Gospel narrative in Byzantine liturgy.
The papers were given in the Danilovsky hotel, the Orthodox theological graduate school Aspirantura and in the premises of the Moscow State University. The presentation in the university context was particularly significant because theology has only recently been recognized as an academic discipline in Russia. The Aspirantura also hosted several post-conference teaching sessions for students and seminary lecturers from all over Russia by members of the symposium (including Margaret Barker, Richard Burridge, Carl Holladay, David Moessner, Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr and Volker Rabens). Along the way, the symposium provided various opportunities for ecumenical encounter through the optional attendance of devotions led by symposium participants of different denominational backgrounds and through the invitation to participate in several Orthodox liturgies, such as the Feast of the Holy Cross led by the Metropolitan Hilarion. (Post-)Conference excursions included the Tretyakov State Gallery and the monastery Sergiyev Posad.
In keeping with a good tradition, the conference proceedings will be published in the Mohr Siebeck’s series “Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament”. Previous conferences were held in in Neamţ (1998), the Rila Monastery (2001), St. Petersburg (2005), Sâmbăta de Sus (2007), Minsk (2010) and Belgrade (2013). The Eighth East-West Symposium of New Testament Scholars is planned to take place 2019.
Metropolitan Hilarion (Moscow, Russia): The “Demythologization” of New Testament Scholarship (Opening Lecture)
Margareta Gruber (Vallendar, Germany): Paschal Imagination – Seeing in the Light of the Resurrection: Jesus as ‘performer’ of his death and resurrection in Jn 2:13-23
Anatoly A. Alexeev (St. Petersburg, Russia): St. John on the Way from Christology to Theology
Tobias Nicklas (Regensburg, Germany): Extra-Canonical Gospels: Their Historical Impact and Theological Contribution
Francis Watson (Durham, Great Britain): Faith, History, and Memory in the Gospel of Mark
Joel Marcus (Durham, NC, USA): Matthew as Historian and Theologian
Cosmin Pricop (Bucharest, Romania): Between Criticism and Patristics: The Transfiguration Story in Mark from an Eastern Point of View
Armand Puig i Tàrrech (Barcelona, Spain): The Polyhedric Approach to the Figure of Jesus in the Canonical Gospels
Mikhail Seleznev (Moscow, Russia): “Theology of the Septuagint” as Praeparatio evangelica?
Vladan Tatalovic (Belgrade, Serbia): The Passion Narrative in Matthew in Slavonic and in Modern Serbian Exegesis
Stefanos Alexopoulos (Washington, DC, USA): The Gospel Narrative in Byzantine Liturgy: An Overview
Final Plenary Session
Carl Holladay (Atlanta, GA, USA), presiding
Panel: Metropolitan Hilarion, William Loader (Perth, Australia), Joel Marcus and Francis Watson
Lauri Thurén (Joensuu, Finland): The Final Countdown – The Last Judgment (Mt 25,31-46) in the Light of Narratology
Ekaterini Tsalampouni (Thessaloniki, Greece): The Character Group of the Disciples in Matthew’s Gospel: Narrative Function and Theological Significance
Manuel Vogel (Jena, Germany): Jesus as Shepherd of the People: Observations towards the Israel-concept in the Gospel of Matthew
Petr Marecek (Olomouc, Czech Republic): The Function and Importance of Matt 28:16-20 in the Gospel of Matthew
Ekaterina Matusova (Moscow, Russia / Tübingen, Germany): Ps. 78:2 (77:2) in Mt 13:35: Historical Perspectives on a Different Translation
Vadim Wittkowsky (Moscow, Russia) / Berlin, Germany): Some Linguistic Arguments for the Priority of Mark and the Secondary Ending of Mark's Gospel as a Countercheck
Stelian Tofana (Cluj-Napoca, Romania): Mark’s Portrait of Jesus
Christos Karakolis (Athens, Greece): Is There Such a Thing as Prophetic Christology in Mark? A Reader-Centered Approach
Andrey Desnitsky (Moscow, Russia): Luke Between History and Theology: Solutions for Translators
Gottfried Schimanowski (Pliezhausen, Germany): The Lord’s Prayer as an elemental part of Luke’s theology
Alexey Somov (Moscow, Russia): Jesus’ Banquet Etiquette (Luke 14:7-11) and the Heavenly Feast: A Cognitive Interpretation
Ivan Miroshnikov (Helsinki, Finland): Two (Men) on a Couch: Luke 17:34 and Parallels (Gos. Thom. 61:1 and Apoc. Zeph. 2:4)
Thomas Schumacher (Fribourg, Switzerland): The Lucan Assumption stories (Luke 24:50-53 and Acts 1:9-11): Their Narrative Function and Theological Relevance within the Lucan Corpus
Vadim Wittkowsky (Moscow, Russia) / Berlin, Germany): The Book of Acts and its Impact on the Understanding of the Third Gospel and on the Solution of the Synoptic Problem
James Buchanan Wallace (Memphis, TN, USA): Of Manna and Eucharist: The Feeding of the Five Thousand in the Gospel of John
Tomás Garcia Huidobro SJ (Moscow, Russia): The Narrative of the Judgment on Jesus in the Fourth Gospel in the Context of the Controversy with Early Merkabah Mysticism
Hans-Ulrich Weidemann (Siegen, Germany): Jesus and the Jews in the Johannine Cana Cycle (Jn 2-4)
Petr Shitikov (Tobolsk, Russia): Cognitive Views on Metaphor in John
Dimitry Bratkin (St. Petersburg, Russia): An ‘Exemplary God-Fearer’ in Luke 7:2-10
Andrey Vdovichenko (Moscow, Russia): Gospel Narrative as a Linguistic Object in and beyond the Communicative Vacuum
Andrei Vinogradov (Moscow, Russia): Polymorphic Christ in non-canonical Acts: Deus ex machina?
Archimandrite Justin (Sinai, Egypt): And Spake of His Exodus: Evoking the Larger Narrative in the Gospel of Saint Luke
Alexander Timofeev (Moscow, Russia): The Location of Pontius Pilate’s Praetorium in the Light of Modern Archaeological Data
Maria Jurovitskaja (Moscow, Russia): Some Considerations about Lk 1:78 and the Septuagint
Dimitry Osipov (Ekaterinburg, Russia): Changing Paradigms in the Study of Early Judaism in the Historiography of the 2nd half of the XX century
Michael Zheltov (Russia): Byzantine Gospel Lectionary. What does the Gospel readings’ sequence tell us?
If there is additional discussion of this review, you may access it through the network, at: http://hsozkult.geschichte.hu-berlin.de/.
Volker Rabens. Review of , Seventh East-West Symposium of New Testament Scholars.
H-Soz-u-Kult, H-Net Reviews.
Copyright © 2017 by H-Net, Clio-online, and the author, all rights reserved. This work may be copied and redistributed for non-commercial, educational purposes, if permission is granted by the author and usage right holders. For permission please contact H-SOZ-U-KULT@H-NET.MSU.EDU.